Poynter Online
Go


Top Story

Who? Here's a Primer on GOP Veep Choice Sarah Palin
Most Recent Articles
Most E-mailed
Recent Comments
Recent Tags
Community Activity

Poynter Training
Poynter Seminars
Small, in-person training experiences.
News University
Today's most popular courses on NewsU, Poynter's e-learning site for journalists.
Webinars
Our online classroom is just a click away. Learn more.
All Webinars
Home > Visual Journalism
Tools: Text Sizeor, Print, e-mail, Permalink, Share
1:20 PM  Aug. 28, 2006
Joe Rosenthal: 1911-2006
By Al Tompkins (More articles by this author)

You, no doubt, have heard that the great World War II photojournalist Joe Rosenthal died Sunday. This is an opportunity to point you toward the back story of his famous picture of the Marines raising the American flag at Iwo Jima. Rosenthal said that, initially, he could not understand what the fuss was about surrounding his photograph.
rosenthal1
AP Photo/Doug Mills
Joe Rosenthal visits Arlington, Va., June 28, 1995.


In Fredrick Voss' "Reporting the War" (written in 1994), you will find this passage, which tells the story of how, early on, some wrongly criticized the now-famous photograph as being "staged":

When Rosenthal looked back on his eleven days of recording the battle for Iwo Jima, it was not that image for which he had the greatest professional fondness. Rather it was one taken in the first hours of the invasion. Landing on the island's beaches hard on the heels of the first wave of marines, Rosenthal had found himself, like the armed men around him, dodging a stiff barrage of enemy fire.


Seeking picture opportunities while remaining mindful of the need to find cover, he was darting from shell crater to shell crater when he spotted the bodies of two dead marines. In that moment, he conceived the idea for a photograph intended to evoke the essence of what he was witnessing. Thus, bringing the bodies of the two fallen men into his camera's focus, he waited for an advancing marine to come within view, and when one did, he took a picture that, in his estimation at least, embodied the "honest ingredients" of what the Iwo Jima story in its early phases was all about -- the dead paving the way so that the living might follow. [See the less-famous photo here.]


Despite the forethought that went into that beach picture, the resulting image did not seemed contrived, which is probably one of the chief reasons why Rosenthal took special pride in it. On the other hand, his picture of the flag-raising on Mount Suribachi four days later -- which, in its compositional perfection, did seem contrived and led to conjectures by some that it had to have been carefully posed.

Read more about the controversy surrounding the famous Rosenthal picture and the rumors that keep it alive.

 

rosenthal2
AP Photo/Joe Rosenthal
An American flag is raised atop Mt. Suribachi, Iwo Jima, on Feb. 23, 1945.
It became, as you know, an icon memoralizing all who died in the Pacific island of Iwo Jima.

 

The picture that Rosenthal captured was not the first flag-raising. That took place before Joe could get to the top of the mountain.


Yes, there was another flag-raising -- and WCCO-TV in Minneapolis produced a documentary about that first flag-raising and the men behind it. If you have not seen this, treat yourself to some great work. In so many ways, it makes Rosenthal's photograph on that fateful day even more remarkable. As you listen to the stories from the Marines about what the conditions were like during the battle, imagine Rosenthal there, in the midst of it all, doing what he could to document it with his camera.  


More resources:
RELATED CONTENT

For more story ideas, see Al's Morning Meeting, by Al Tompkins.

Get Al's Morning Meeting updates as an RSS feed:
* Copy this link and add it to your feed reader

Sign up to receive Al's Morning Meeting by e-mail:
* Click here (sent Monday-Friday at 7 a.m.)

Tools: Print, e-mail, Permalink, Comment On This Article, Share
Recent Comments:
Rosenthal Picture
Joe Rosenthal's famous picture and the camera he took the picture with is here in Rochester, NY on display at the George Eastman House for those of you who are interested. The link can be found through my station's website at www.rnews.com.
Veronica Brown, 8:54 AM August 22, 2006
Read All Comments (1 comments)
Username
Password
New User? Signup Now
Poynter Careers
Ask The Recruiter Ask The Recruiter Friday: Can a Journalist be a Singer?
Colleen on Careers Colleen on Careers You Worked Hard to Get the Interview, Make it Count